When forecasts disagree, start by matching their purpose, time range and definitions. Forecasters use numerical models for different purposes, and results can change when forecasts are updated. Agreement across several screens doesn’t settle what will happen on your mountain. This guide uses the Japan Meteorological Agency’s explanations to help you interpret the differences and adapt your plan.
How forecasts can come to differ
Forecasts use satellite data, surface and upper-air observations, and numerical model results. Model calculations contain errors, and new observations and runs can change the forecast from one issue to the next. Models also run on different schedules. Check the latest forecast before departing, even if a previous issue showed sunshine.
In Japan, providers licensed by the head of the Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) may issue their own forecasts. Their predictions for the same place can differ. Many broadcasters get forecasts from JMA or licensed providers, so the source can affect what appears. Differences between screens sometimes come down to the forecaster or the time of the last update.
Models cover different scales and forecast horizons
JMA uses multiple numerical models. For heavy rain in the next few hours to about half a day, it uses a local model with 1 km grid spacing and a local ensemble with 2 km spacing. For potentially hazardous weather up to about three days ahead, it uses a mesoscale model and ensemble with 5 km spacing. Typhoon forecasts and forecasts up to a week ahead use a global model with about 13 km spacing and a global ensemble with about 27 km spacing. The global ensemble also supports forecasts up to two weeks ahead.
JMA’s model table lists the mesoscale model, mesoscale ensemble and global model for prefectural and gridded forecasts, and the global model and global ensemble for the weekly outlook. The weather features a model can represent depend on grid spacing. JMA gives roughly 100 km or more as the scale of features for the global model, tens of kilometres or more for the mesoscale model, and under 10 km for the local model. Even the local model cannot adequately represent individual cumulonimbus clouds.
First check the period and area covered. Fine grid spacing doesn’t guarantee a correct summit forecast. The JMA model guide consulted on November 4, 2026 describes the scales and roles of the models. It gives no ranking for an individual hiking trail. Evaluate what each model covers before relying on its name.
Three reasons counting forecasts can mislead
Simply counting forecasts can be misleading when their sources or coverage differ. The editors suggest paying attention to three points based on how JMA describes the forecasting process.
First, the forecasts may not be independent. Broadcasters may use a common provider, and the same outlook can appear on several screens. Five matches can therefore be five displays of one forecast. Check the providers’ own descriptions to see what they disclose about their sources.
Second, forecast horizons and reliability vary. The weekly outlook gives a confidence grade for whether precipitation will occur from day three onward. Treat a distant outlook and an immediate forecast differently. When JMA predicts precipitation seven to fifteen hours ahead, it combines mesoscale and local model results while accounting for their performance at the starting time. Counting website displays doesn’t reproduce this procedure.
Third, the definitions may differ. Precipitation probability refers to at least 1 mm in the forecast area and doesn’t say how much will fall. Weather icons prioritize rain or snow when forecast. If the service has to choose between cloud and sunshine, it shows the condition expected to last longer. The JMA gridded forecast shows the representative weather in a cell every three hours. A count of “rain” and “cloudy” can group together results that mean different things.
Compare forecasts by source, forecast period and definition. This is the editors’ suggested approach.
A one-page worksheet for forecasts that disagree
Keep the forecast settings and disagreements together on paper or in a notes app. Here’s one way to do it.
Step 1. For each forecast, record its name, issue time, valid date and area, including whether it covers a forecast district or a grid cell. Leave the source blank when it’s unknown.
Step 2. Choose the main forecast based on how close the hike is. The Obihiro Weather Station recommends starting with the weekly outlook, which goes up to one week ahead. Check nearby regions and surrounding dates to allow for shifts. For finer timing, begin looking roughly three days out.
Step 3. Group differences into four areas: whether precipitation is forecast, when it could fall, how much could fall, and how each source defines its terms. Some differences disappear when you compare equivalent items. Use separate columns for the probability of at least 1 mm and for gridded three-hour precipitation totals, shown as cell averages in six bands.
Step 4. For differences that remain, write down what you would do in either case. For example, “Turn back here if the rain starts earlier,” or “Continue only if the outlook remains favorable.” Leave room to turn back or postpone while the outlook is uncertain.
Step 5. Replace your notes with the latest issue as departure approaches. The day before and the day of the hike, check the most recent of the 05:00, 11:00 and 17:00 prefectural forecasts. Short-range precipitation forecasts are less reliable farther ahead, so use the latest one. The gridded forecast for the mountain and the past 72 hours of rainfall can help assess trails and streams. Near typhoons and stationary early-summer or autumn rain fronts, the weather can change markedly. Consider checking more often, and include the days after your planned descent.
Stop on steady footing and leave room for others to pass before looking at your screen or adding notes. If there’s nowhere suitable, wait until you can stop safely.
Summary: compare source, forecast period and definition
When forecasts disagree, line up their sources, time windows, coverage and definitions. Different screens can share the same data. Treat any differences that remain as uncertainty, and keep options to shorten, reschedule or cancel. Note issue times and make a fresh decision using the latest forecast before you leave.
References and sources
- JMA: Weather forecasts
- JMA Obihiro Weather Station: Before you go into the mountains
- JMA: Questions about weather forecasts and weather charts
- JMA: Gridded weather forecasts
- JMA: Types of numerical weather prediction models
- JMA: Precipitation nowcasts and short-range forecasts
- JMA: Weekly weather forecast